Home / / ICANN slammed by governments for shambolic policies

ICANN slammed by governments for shambolic policies

Governmental Advisory Committee issues report labelling procedures ‘complex, lengthy, ambiguous’

ICANN slammed by governments for shambolic policies
The document openly condemned ICANN’s policies on two-letter second-level domains.

US-based Web domain administrator, the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) has come under fire from governments around the world over the organisation's level of bureaucracy, The Register reported.

The stinging indictment was issued in a report from ICANN's own Governmental Advisory Committee (GAC). The document decried "complex, lengthy and ambiguous" processes and openly condemned ICANN's policies on two-letter second-level domains, which are commonly reserved for country codes such as ".ae", ".de" and ".uk".

More than 500 new top-level domains are being added to the Internet and another 500 are to follow. According to The Register, an increasing number of Web registrars have called for the abolition of restrictions on two-letter domains, so that organisation would be able to , for example, register "ae.horse" or "uk.music".

But while the GAC report called for relaxation of some policies, some governments raised concerns over the policing of certain domains, where trust was implied by the name, to prevent disreputable organisations presenting themselves as trustworthy. The report listed 100 such domains, including ".dentist", ".kids", ".hospital", ".bank" and ".mortgage".

Continues on next page>>

ICANN, however, has repeatedly left the policing of TLDs to registrars, encouraging the introduction of "public interest commitments" (PICS) to the application process.

Despite the GAC's concerns, however, ICANN has repeatedly refused to introduce verification requirements for the top-level domains. Instead it has introduced a self-regulation approach, where registry operators can add "public interest commitments" (PICS) to their applications that outline what they will do to limit or prevent abuse. Naturally, the GAC isn't happy.

"The GAC believes that its advised affirmative requirement for verification of credentials at the time of registration goes much further to meeting the goal of mitigating consumer harm and fraud than an after-the-fact complaint system," the group said in its report.

The GAC also highlighted the Public Interest Commitments Dispute Resolution Procedure (PICDRP) that ICANN uses to discipline organisations as vague and ineffective.

"At present, the GAC considers the PICDRP to be complex, lengthy, and ambiguous, raising questions as to its effectiveness in addressing serious threats," the group wrote.

Follow us to get the most comprehensive technology news in UAE delivered fresh from our social media accounts on Facebook, Twitter, Youtube, and listen to our Weekly Podcast. Click here to sign up for our weekly newsletter on curated technology news in the Middle East and Worldwide.

REGISTER NOW | Webinar Event | Security you can bank on – Safeguarding the Middle East’s financial sector

Presented in partnership with security and network specialist Cybereason, the second in the three part webinar series will bring together a panel of experts to discuss how banks and financial institutions are evolving their service offering while simultaneously staying one step ahead of the cyber criminals who seek to bring their operations crashing to the ground.