Where am I? Home /


BREAKING NEWS :

Flag plays down net blackout conspiracy theories

By Dylan Bowman on Monday, February 04, 2008

Repair work on the UAE cable has already begun

Repair work on the UAE cable has already begun

Flag Telecom on Monday played down conspiracy theories over the recent damage to undersea cables that has seriously disrupted internet and international telecoms services across the region.

Two intercontinental cables connecting Europe and Asia were cut off the coast of Egypt on Wednesday, followed by breaks in two more cables off the UAE coast on Friday. Flag owns two of the affected cables.

The initial breaks affected internet access and international calls in Egypt, the Gulf and south Asia, while disruption resulting from damage to the latter two was centred around the Gulf region.

The location of the breaks and short space of time in which they have happened has sparked fears the cables were intentionally damaged by the US and Israel to deprive Iran of internet access.

"It seems now to be way beyond the realm of coincidence that a further 4th critical international communications cable should break within seven days," one ArabianBusiness.com reader commented.
Story continues below
advertisement

"Clearly Iran, who was most affected, would gain nothing from such an action and is perhaps the target of those responsible," said another reader.

Those theories were fuelled further on Monday when Egypt said damage to the cables in the Mediterranean Sea was not caused by ships, as previously thought.

Egypt's Transport Ministry said footage recorded by onshore video cameras of the location of the cables shows no maritime traffic in the area when the cables were damaged.

"The ministry's maritime transport committee reviewed footage covering the period of 12 hours before and 12 hours after the cables were cut and no ships sailed the area," a statement by the Communications Ministry said.

"The area is also marked on maps as a no-go zone and it is therefore ruled out that the damage to the cables was caused by ships."

It is not clear how badly Iran's internet access has been affected by the cable breaks.

The Iranian embassy in Abu Dhabi told ArabianBusiness.com that "everything is fine", but internet connectivity reports on the web, citing a router in Tehran, appear to indicate that there is currently no connection to the outside world.

No one at the US embassy in Abu Dhabi was immediately available to comment.

A spokesperson for Flag said the cause of the breaks will not be known until repair ships reach the site of the damage.

The spokesperson admitted it did seem like a bit of a coincidence that all four were damaged within such a short space of time, but said it would be difficult to find the exact location of the cables.

"I think it is doubtful [the cable damage was intentional]," the spokesperson told ArabianBusiness.com.

Repair ships are expected to arrive at the site of the breaks in the Mediterranean on Tuesday and Friday.

The breaches are in segments of two intercontinental cables known as Sea-ME-We-4 and Flag Europe-Asia.

A ship was expected to depart Abu Dhabi port on Monday to fix the break in the third cable, called Falcon, off the coast of Dubai between the UAE and Oman.

The fourth break is located between the Qatari island of Haloul and the UAE island of Das. The cause of damage is not yet known, but ArabianBusiness.com has been told unofficially the problem is power related.

Internet problems continue with fourth cable break
Services in Qatar seriously disrupted by damage to cable linking Gulf state to UAE.

Internet crisis deepens
Third undersea cable break between UAE and Oman adds to web woes after two breaks just days earlier.



User Comments (6 comments)

Cut Cables
Posted by Hugechurbes, Nottingham, UK on 6 February 2008 at 20:02 UAE time


Paranoia is a disease in all of our modern societies, East and West, North and South! Things happen, sometimes for no reason, 'in threes or fours'. If we are not careful, we will be blaming someone (USA? UK? Russia? Does it matter whom?) for freak bad weather...now there's a thought given the recent flooding on our roads. Or maybe it was just the weather on it's own?
Electrical Opticals
Posted by Alexander, Dubai, UAE on 5 February 2008 at 10:17 UAE time


Sorry to be an anorak, Graham, but the submarine fibre optic cables used in telecommunications do, indeed, carry power. They're not just optical strands: there's a surrounding segment of steel cable that carries a power supply.

One reason that sharks are so fond of attacking these cables is that they create electromagnetic eddies: sharks' teeth are often found in cable that's brought up from the Gulf and Indian Ocean.
Undersea cable cutting
Posted by congressive on 5 February 2008 at 10:04 UAE time


Unlike electric signal-based telephone lines, in order to tap a fiber optic cable, it must be cut. If someone wanted to intercept all communications in and out of the Middle East, these four cables would suffice.

This would be completely in line with GW Bush's FISA plan, or it could be a freak coincidence...
Non-Interventionism
Posted by freerifleman on 5 February 2008 at 10:00 UAE time


These types of things would just be coincidence if the US would keep their hands to themselves. Why can't we follow Thomas Jefferson's advice about non-interventionism?

Ron Paul 2008!
Well, it Sure Wasn't Blofeld!
Posted by Louie Tedesco, Dubai on 5 February 2008 at 08:33 UAE time

Whether the breakage of four undersea cables within less than one week's time is coincidental or not really isn't important at this juncture - broke is broke. For those who don't know, yes, there are submarines and autonomous submersibles which can operate undetected and cut submerged cables. Guess who controls and operates such technological machines? Hint: it's not Hollywood, Bollywood nor James Bond's fictional enemies.

The point being missed by the media, the public and Arab governments is the vulnerability of such critical lifelines from the Gulf to the outside world. In essence, we here are allowed to use the internet on the whims of Western powers who can disrupt undersea cables and satellite based systems at a moments notice. While glitzy projects here always make news headlines, the lack of well protected, redundant infrastructure is ignored. The concept of protecting and hardening critical infrastructure goes beyond the convenience of email and internet usage. More importantly it entails redundant communications systems which are properly maintained and are connected to at least two independent sources of power supply. When the electrical power fails I'm unable to even make a telephone call, neither from my land - nor mobile phone. This leaves the population with no way to call for outside help in case of fire, crime, medical or other emergency - is this not a bit more critical than being unable to send an email or place an internet pizza order?

Providing reliable public infrastructure systems is a bit more complex than merely fencing in the telephone exchange, installing GSM towers atop buildings and plugging them into a power outlet or putting signage on a buoy "caution - undersea cable - please stay away". When you see emergency responders and police authorities here communicating with mobile telephones rather than with secure portable radio equipment you ought to wonder why the developed countries make their personnel use professional equipment that will still operate during disasters, after earthquakes and when normal electrical power has failed - all the while recording what is transmitted.

PS: Please also fix the drainage. It will rain again, eventually.
submarine cable breaks.
Posted by Graham, Canada on 5 February 2008 at 02:34 UAE time

RE: "The cause of damage is not yet known, but ArabianBusiness.com has been told unofficially the problem is power related."

I find this answer to the problem to be at best uninformed, these cables are optical devices and not electrically conducting, thus how can the problem be power related. If the problem was at the receiving or transmitting end then such an analysis would be germane, buts as the cables have "broken" such and explanation is disingenuous at best.
The timing and the situation of these breaks seems to be purposeful and planned. There are only two countries for whom such an event would provide any sort of benefit and those are Israel and the USA, both of which have aspirations beyond their borders.

It would also be in keeping with their long term strategy of asymmetrical warfare by keeping their economic and military opponents ham stringed and sidetracked.
All posts are sent to the administrator for review and are published only after approval. ITP.net reserves the right to remove any comment at any time for any reason. Please keep your responses appropriate and on topic.
Name *
( Remmber Me )
Email *
(Your email address will not be published)
City
Country
Subject *
Comment *
Security Code * Code
 


Please click post only once - your comment will not be published immediately.


Competitions

WIN Creative's Super Box of sound stuff

Ends On Sunday, 15 June 2008

Whether you’re a laptop user who’s fed up with the basic audio being pumped out by your machine, or a desktop owner with a lackluster sound card installed, the USB-based Creative Sound Blaster...


Advertising Features


For editorial enquiries contact
Mark Sutton
mark.sutton
@itp.com
To advertise, contact
Richard O'Sullivan
+971 4 210 8548
or richard.osullivan
@itp.com


Arabian Computer News Channel Middle East Channel Middle East - Arabic Charged CommsMEA Network Middle East Windows Middle East Windows Middle East - Arabic ALL ITP TITLES